MCLB Summary Chapter 6

MCLB Chapter 6: Leaving No Child Behind: Overhauling NCLB
--Monty Neill

No Child Left Behind cannot “fulfill its lofty promises” as it is written. The objectives of the law are laudable, but cannot be accomplished through heavy use of standardized testing and punitive sanctions. NCLB is underfunded, and promotes a public perception of widespread school failure where none exists.

Instead, schools must follow principles for authentic accountability. (They should NOT be held accountable for factors beyond their control, like poverty and “the historical consequences of racism.”) Ten principles include: a shared vision and goals; adequate resources used well; participation and democracy; prioritizing goals; multiple forms of evidence (the portfolio approach); inclusion; improvement; equity; balance bottom-up and top-down accountability; and interventions. Time must be allowed for any changes in schools to take effect, and severe penalties like “reconstitution” should only be considered if nothing else has worked—for there is no evidence that reconstitution improves the quality of instruction. A national campaign and a commitment to reclaiming quality educational practices will allow us to better achieve NCLB’s stated goals without the need to suffer from the law’s many negatives.